Is it permissible to work as a lawyer?

Syed Bukhari

Is it permissible to work as a lawyer?

The law profession (Lawyer) itself is not prohibited in Islam. Working as a lawyer involves acting as an agent or representative for someone in legal disputes or claims. This type of deputation or representation is generally allowed in Islamic law. However, a lawyer must exercise due diligence and careful consideration before taking on a case.

If the case involves restoring rights that were wrongfully taken away, then it would be permissible for the lawyer to argue on behalf of the client to have those rights restored and injustice halted. This falls under the principle of cooperating in righteousness and piety in Islam.

However, if the case aims to usurp people’s rights or facilitates transgression, a Muslim lawyer should refrain from representing such a case. This would constitute cooperation in sinful acts, which Allah warns against in the Quran:

“Help one another in righteousness and piety, but do not help one another in sin and transgression. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty.” (Quran 5:2)

Islamic Scholars Point of View – Legal profession

Some Islamic scholars have provided more guidance on the permissibility of the legal profession:

Shaykh Ibn Baaz ruled that there is nothing inherently wrong with being a lawyer, as it involves legally representing clients in disputes and defenses. However, the lawyer must seek justice and truthfulness and not deliberately lie or misrepresent facts.

Shaykh Al-Fawzaan said advocacy is allowed if the case is legitimate and the lawyer argues based on true facts without deception. If the case facilitates transgression or falsehood, like dealing with riba (interest), then it is prohibited to represent it. But helping a weak person attain their rights is encouraged.

Muslim Be a Lawyer

permissible to work as a lawyer

Being a lawyer is not prohibited in Islam if core principles are upheld:

  • Ensuring the case is lawful and just
  • Not facilitating falsehood or transgression
  • Maintaining truthfulness and avoiding deception
  • Upholding justice, particularly for the weak and oppressed

Can a Muslim Be a Lawyer in a Secular System?

Living under a secular system does not necessarily prohibit being a lawyer, as long as the intention is to defend rights and prevent injustice. A wronged person may be compelled to use secular laws to attain their rights if no other option exists. Otherwise, widespread oppression could prevail.

If the law grants more rights than permitted in Islam, taking those excess rights would be unlawful. One should only take what is rightfully theirs under Islamic law.

Referring a case to secular courts in order to reclaim usurped rights or prevent wrongdoing is permissible out of necessity. The sin is on those who replaced divine laws, not those forced to resort to them.

Prominent Islamic scholar Ibn Al-Qayyim affirmed this view. So within a secular legal system, a Muslim may practice law with the aim of upholding justice and fighting wrongdoing, especially for the weak and oppressed. This is an act of piety, not sin.

Advice for Prospective Muslim Lawyers

Given the principles above, becoming a lawyer is not inherently prohibited in Islam. The legal field needs pious, trustworthy Muslim lawyers to uphold justice.

That said, one must be cautious in selecting cases and clients. Refuse any case that violates Islamic law or facilitates transgression. Research each case thoroughly and avoid any doubtful or dubious matters.

Make upholding morals and justice your guiding purpose, not fame, reputation or material gain. Do not engage in deception, manipulation or any unethical means during cases.

Also be reasonable in legal fees charged to clients. Avoid creating undue financial burdens. Seek a livelihood but also uphold the Prophetic principles of moderation and looking out for the needy.

With this balanced approach, the legal profession can be an honorable calling for Muslims, a path to defending rights and principles ordained by the Almighty.

When Does Practicing Law Become Prohibited?

While Islam permits adherents to become lawyers, under certain circumstances it can become prohibited, for example:

  • Knowingly defending an unjust cause – If one takes on a case despite recognizing the client’s claim is false or unjust, arguing on their behalf would be unlawful.
  • Facilitating transgression or falsehood – If a case involves matters clearly prohibited in Islam, like interest (riba), it would be forbidden to aid the client.
  • Misrepresenting facts or misleading the court – Lying, presenting false evidence or concealing facts are all prohibited means that make a case unlawful.
  • Aiding the wealthy against the weak – If a lawyer utilizes his skills and status to help an oppressor gain an advantage over people of lesser means or status, this would contravene Islamic principles of justice.
  • Charging exorbitant fees – Taking advantage of a client’s desperation by charging excessive fees in exchange for legal services is prohibited in Islam. Moderation should be exercised.

So in brief, if a Muslim lawyer employs deception, facilitates transgression, obscures facts, or promotes injustice through their representation of a case, this would be deemed unlawful and sinful. The ends do not justify improper means in Islam. Honesty, ethics and morality must take precedence over any professional pursuits.

You can also learn, IS ACTING PERMISSIBLE IN ISLAM?

FAQ’s

Q: Is it forbidden (haram) to be a lawyer in Islam?

A: Being a lawyer is not inherently forbidden in Islam. The legal profession is permissible as long as one upholds Islamic ethics and principles, like honesty, justice and avoiding harm. However, if a lawyer engages in deception or promotes injustice, that would be prohibited.

Q: What makes being a lawyer haram?

A: Factors that can make being a lawyer haram include knowingly arguing false claims, facilitating transactions prohibited by Islam, employing deception, aiding oppressors against the weak, obscuring facts and charging exorbitant fees. Violating Islamic laws and ethics in the course of legal work makes it unlawful.

Q: Can a Muslim be a corporate lawyer?

A: Yes, a Muslim can be a corporate lawyer as long as they ensure clients abide by laws and ethics. Advising companies on lawful activities and compliance is permissible. However, getting involved in any fraudulent or unethical corporate activities would be haram.

Q: Is it permissible for a Muslim to be a criminal defense lawyer?

A: It depends on the case specifics. Defending an innocent client or ensuring a fair trial aligns with Islamic principles. But knowingly defending a guilty criminal through deception or unethical means would be prohibited. A balanced, ethical approach is required.

Q: Can a Muslim woman work as a lawyer?

A: Yes, it is permissible for a Muslim woman to be a lawyer and practice law ethically. Women have equal rights to men in this regard. They should maintain modest Islamic dress code when interacting with the legal system. Overall, the same principles apply to both genders.

Final Verdict

The legal profession is not categorically prohibited in Islam. Rather, it can be an honorable calling to uphold justice and give voice to the oppressed, which are sacred duties. However, Muslim lawyers must be wary of any unethical or fraudulent activities, and avoid facilitating sinful transactions prohibited by the Shariah. With a strong moral compass rooted in the Quran and Sunnah, practicing law can be a rewarding and respectable profession for Muslims. The justice system relies on principled, honest lawyers to function properly, and Muslims can fill this role in a manner that earns divine reward.

Leave a comment